INT. A SMALL OFFICE - MORNING The printer is making a sound nobody has heard before. FIRST Is that normal? SECOND It's been doing that since Tuesday. FIRST And nobody said anything? SECOND We said it to each other.
The premise is doing the work the dialogue should be doing. Every line explains the printer; none of them react to it, and the scene ends because it runs out of people rather than because it lands.
The comic ideathe game
A comic idea is identifiable, but the scene does not commit to it. Either a second odd element competes for the same attention, or the idea is only named (a character says what is strange) and never seen happening.
It's been doing that since Tuesday.
The comic idea: 2 of 5
Escalationheightening
The scene moves, but the game does not come with it. The second beat brings in an unrelated element, or a surprise that breaks the logic the first beat set.
We said it to each other.
Escalation: 2 of 5
The last linethe button
The last moment is the strongest and the scene stops there. But it is the ending the setup promised, or the laugh is buried in the middle of the final line.
The printer is making a sound nobody has heard before.
The last line: 3 of 5
Character voice
Cover the character names and the lines are interchangeable. Nothing in the detail, reference or rhythm belongs to one person rather than another.
And nobody said anything?
Character voice: 1 of 5
Compressioneconomy
Tight except for one thing: a single line could go without loss, or one point is stated that the reader could have inferred.
Is that normal?
Compression: 3 of 5