How You’re Scored
This is the whole rubric. Every rung is written down before you write a word, and the grader is given these exact sentences — there is no second, secret version of this page.
A rung you have not reached is information, not a rebuke. The useful question while reading is which sentence describes what you did last time.
Read one rung at a time
View all rubricThe comic ideathe game
There is no single comic idea. The lines are talk, attitude, or several odd things that compete, and none is developed. Nothing here could be pointed at and called the joke.
Half-hour comedy
The comic ideathe game
- 1There is no single comic idea. The lines are talk, attitude, or several odd things that compete, and none is developed. Nothing here could be pointed at and called the joke.
- 2A comic idea is identifiable, but the scene does not commit to it. Either a second odd element competes for the same attention, or the idea is only named (a character says what is strange) and never seen happening.
- 3One idea is shown happening, and the rest of the scene is played straight around it. It is the obvious reading of the premise, the idea the premise handed over.
- 4As 3, and the idea is the writer's own angle on the premise rather than the premise restated. One line breaks the scene's reality around it, though: the scene shows a character acknowledging the joke, by winking at it, commenting on how odd it is, or playing it for a laugh instead of straight. A character whose habit in the world is doing bits does not break it by doing one.
- 5As 4, and the straight world holds in every line. The idea is something true inside the premise that was not visible until this writer pointed at it.
Escalationheightening
- 1Nothing grows. The second beat restates the first, or the scene stalls, and the situation at the end is the situation at the start.
- 2The scene moves, but the game does not come with it. The second beat brings in an unrelated element, or a surprise that breaks the logic the first beat set.
- 3The second beat follows from the first and raises it. The raise can be bigger, smaller, closer to home or more public. It is the expected step, though, and the reader sees it coming.
- 4As 3, and the step is not the expected one. But it needs something new to make it work: a fact, an arrival or an object that neither the premise nor an earlier beat had established. New dialogue on its own is not something new.
- 5As 4, and the step follows only from what the scene had already put in place. It is surprising in the moment and, looking back, the only place the scene could have gone.
The last linethe button
- 1The scene ends on setup, trails past its best moment, or closes on the weakest thing on the page.
- 2The scene ends on a joke, but the laugh is diluted on the way out by an explanation, a tag, or a reaction that says what just happened.
- 3The last moment is the strongest and the scene stops there. But it is the ending the setup promised, or the laugh is buried in the middle of the final line.
- 4As 3, and the ending is not the promised one, with the laugh landing at the very end of the line, action or silence. But it comes from outside the scene: a new arrival, a new fact or an interruption, rather than something the scene set up.
- 5As 4, and the ending pays off something the scene itself put in place (a line, an object or a fact) without flagging it as a setup. A flag is a line that announces the ending is coming, such as saying what a key opens just before opening it; a plain earlier mention is a setup, not a flag. It does not explain itself on the way out.
Character voice
- 1Cover the character names and the lines are interchangeable. Nothing in the detail, reference or rhythm belongs to one person rather than another.
- 2One character is drawn and the others could be anyone. A deliberate straight man whose reactions are specific to them counts as drawn, not as anyone.
- 3Every speaker can be told apart, but as types (the boss, the sarcastic one), by a broad register or attitude rather than as particular people.
- 4As 3, and every speaker is a particular person: a want or a way of seeing shows in how they handle the moment. But the jokes are lines rather than character jokes. Handed to another character, most would be just as funny.
- 5As 4, and the comedy depends on who is speaking. The same words in another character's mouth would not be funny.
Compressioneconomy
- 1The scene explains itself. Characters state what they feel or narrate what the reader can see, or the opening spends lines arriving at the situation. Either is enough for this rung.
- 2It arrives at the situation, but two or more lines could go without loss, or one idea is said twice.
- 3Tight except for one thing: a single line could go without loss, or one point is stated that the reader could have inferred.
- 4Nothing could go and nothing is over-explained, but most lines do only one job each. The scene is efficient rather than compressed.
- 5As 4, and it enters after the situation has started, with most lines doing two jobs at once (advancing, revealing or landing). Length never stands in for substance.
How this rubric was chosen
Why these five
Chosen from criteria that recur across craft sources, then filtered by what is actually assessable in a 3-5 line scene. game/heightening/button are the three stages of one comic object (idea, movement, payoff), which lines up with the humour-research account of a joke as an incongruity the reader then resolves.
Rules that apply to every rung
Score the highest rung whose every condition is met; a scene with a higher rung's quality but a lower rung's failure is scored at the lower rung. A missing basic caps the score: an original idea that is only named, never shown, scores at most 2 on the comic idea. Size is not quality: bigger, louder or longer never earns a rung, and a step down or inward can be the escalation. The last moment can be a line, an action or a silence. Choices are judged on their own terms, not by resemblance to the example scene.
How the rungs are built
Since v2 (30 Oct 2026) every ladder is cumulative: each rung contains everything below it plus one more thing, so a higher score can never describe worse writing. 1 = not there; 2 = there, with exactly one named defect that undoes it; 3 = working, but the obvious version; 4 = working and not obvious, with exactly one named shortfall; 5 = working, not obvious, and held throughout. No rung is told apart from its neighbour by a degree word.
What a three-to-five line scene can test
A 3-5 line scene has room for one escalation and a last line, so that is what it is scored on. Asking for three escalations at this length would punish correct writing. Deliberately excluded as unassessable here: rule of three, act structure, act-outs, runners, callbacks, A/B story weaving, character arc, scene turn, pacing variation, world-building, escalation ceiling.
What is deliberately not scored
'Does the cold open set up the A-story' is not scored: many sitcom cold opens stand alone, and this exercise gives you no episode to set up. Marketability, theme, and emotional engagement are excluded because this grades craft, not commercial viability.
Why compression is scored at all
Comedy rewards compression: rooms cut a scene at its funniest line, and screenwriters are taught to enter a scene as late as they can. Some AI judges have been measured preferring longer answers and others shorter ones; it depends on the model. Compression is scored so that length can never stand in for substance, and its level-5 anchor says so directly.