Learn · Half-hour comedy · Chapter 3 of 9
Where the laugh word goes
Many first drafts reach a funny line near the end and then keep going. This chapter shows you where to stop and how to end on the laugh.
In this chapter
Start here
A cold open is the short scene before a show's opening titles. Its last line is called the button. Here, your button is scored from 1 to 5, and each level is called a rung.
Read this draft once. Notice where you laugh, if you do.
DERMOTSomeone has eaten one word off my birthday cake.
HATTIEHas someone.
DERMOTIt was a card from all of us. In icing. On a cake.
HATTIEI ate the "us." I don't sign things I wasn't asked about, and nobody asked me, so I took my part of it off.
The laugh is in the last line, at the word "us." After it, the scene spends 20 more words explaining a joke the reader already understood.
Most junior writers think the fix is a better joke. Usually the fix is to stop sooner, and to end on the laugh. Where should a scene stop, and what should it end on?
Idea 1 of 3
Stop on the laugh
Junior writers rarely lack a funny line. They often keep writing after it. After the laugh they add an explanation, a reaction, or one more step of plot. Each extra line takes the short pause that the laugh needed. In this chapter we say that the extra line uses up the laugh.
In a writers' room (the team that writes a TV comedy), writers want almost every scene to end on a joke, with nothing after it.
HATTIEI ate the (circled) "us." (cut) I don't sign things I wasn't asked about, and nobody asked me, so I took my part of it off.
Cut everything after the laugh.
Check yourselfNadia asks Felix who used her good knife to open a parcel. He says it was an important parcel. She asks what was in it. Which line should end the scene?
Go deeper
Why it works. A laugh needs a short silence. One sitcom writing teacher puts it plainly: people won't laugh while you are still talking. A line after the laugh fills that silence.
How to spot it. Read your scene aloud and stop at the funniest word. If there are lines after it, ask what each one adds. If it explains, reacts or adds plot, cut it and read the scene again.
Character helps. In this world, Hattie rarely says more than six words. The long draft line is out of character as well as too long.
What it is not. Stopping on the laugh does not mean you must solve the problem in the scene. A cold open ends on its best joke, not on a solution.
Idea 2 of 3
The laugh word goes last
Most jokes have one word or short phrase that reveals the joke. Stand-up teachers call it the punch word. In this chapter we call it the laugh word. Put it at the end of the line, so nothing comes between the reveal and the laugh.
A line can be funny and still hide its laugh word in the middle. Then the line ends on a weaker word. Usually you fix this by changing the order of the words. Keep the meaning, and keep the words as close as you can.
The last moment does not have to be a line. It can be an action or a silence, like a look or a door closing. The rule is the same: the laugh lands at the very end, and nothing comes after it.
NADIAYou're leaving? It's nine o'clock.
RUBENI have to be up early.
NADIAWhat for?
RUBENMy ex-wife is giving a lecture (circled) about me tomorrow at nine.
The laugh is "about me." Move it to the end.
Check yourselfWhich version of Ruben's last line ends on the laugh?
Go deeper
Where it comes from. Several stand-up teachers give this rule. The word that reveals the joke goes last, and moving it earlier weakens the joke. Some comics hold back the punch line on purpose. That is a choice for a long stand-up set, not for a scene of five lines.
How to spot it. Underline the word or phrase that makes the line funny. If it is not at the end, rebuild the line so that it is.
Where the sources disagree. Some writers teach a pause before the punch word. The evidence on pauses points both ways. The rule about word order has more support.
Idea 3 of 3
Pay off what you planted
The strongest buttons pay off something that the scene already put down. A plant is a detail that looks like plain setup. The payoff is the last line that makes that detail funny.
An announced plant tells the reader what is coming, so the ending is the one the setup promised. That is rung 3. A surprise from outside the scene, such as someone walking in, is rung 4. A quiet plant looks like ordinary talk, so its payoff surprises the reader and still comes from the scene. That is rung 5.
PAULA(in oven gloves, putting down the last of fourteen plates) You'll want to thank people. I wrote a list.
RAYI don't need a list. I know who did what.
RAY(to the table) I'd like to thank the butcher, the wine shop, and (circled) whoever cooked.
Two quiet plants. The oven gloves, and Ray saying no to the list.
Check yourselfEach of these could be Paula's first line. Which one announces the ending, so the toast arrives on time?
Go deeper
How experienced writers find a payoff. When they need an ending, they look back through the scene first. They look for a phrase that could come back, an object that could return, or an idea that started to show. Only then do they write something new.
How to spot it. Cover your last line. Can a reader guess it from the lines above? If they can, the plant was announced. Make the plant smaller, or put it earlier.
Worked rewrite
The reaction line
Nico has been looking after the fish on the front desk. Read the draft, then choose the fix.
ELLEHave you been feeding the fish on reception?
NICOEvery morning for a month.
ELLEThat's a screensaver.
NICO(laughing) Oh no.
Check yourselfWhat is the smallest fix?
Worked rewrite
The hidden laugh word
Oz got a part in a play. Birdie asks about it.
BIRDIEWhat's the part?
OZA tree, but a tree that's really central to the story.
Check yourselfWhich rewrite keeps what Oz means and ends on the laugh?
Junior trap
Explaining the joke
Choose the line that uses up the laugh.
Traps found: 0 of 1
Why smart writers do it. They worry that the reader missed the joke. Usually the reader did not.
The correction. Delete the explanation. Trust the line before it.
Junior trap
The reaction line
Choose the line that uses up the laugh.
Traps found: 0 of 1
Why smart writers do it. On set, an actor's face would carry the moment. On the page, the reader's own laugh does that job.
The correction. End on the button. If you need the reaction, put it at the start of the next scene.
Junior trap
Telling the reader what's coming
Choose the line that gives the ending away.
Traps found: 0 of 1
Why smart writers do it. They want the reader to be ready for the joke. A reader who is ready laughs less.
The correction. Cut the warning. Let the character's own lines show what is coming.
How senior writers work
Write five endings. Keep the best surprise that comes from the scene.
Instead of: That'll do.Write: Five endings, then choose.The first ending is often the one the setup promised. Experienced writers expect that and keep going.
Find the laugh word. Move it to the end.
Instead of: ...so I took my part of it off.Write: I ate the "us."You can check this. Nothing should come after the funniest moment on the page.
Look back before you write something new.
Instead of: a new joke for the endingWrite: the list Ray said no toA payoff from inside the scene gets a laugh, and the scene feels complete.
Read the last line aloud, then stop.
Instead of: one more lineWrite: cut to the titlesIf you still want to add a line, check that the last line is the funniest one. If it is, stop.
Trade-offs
A clean button
The laugh word is last, the line is short, and the scene ends at once. It can sound like a writer, not like this person.
A line this person would say
The words and the rhythm belong to the character. It can run on past the laugh.
How to decide. Keep the character's words and change their order. If no order works, rewrite the joke, or give the last line to another character.
End on a joke
The scene ends on its biggest laugh. Writers' rooms expect this from almost every scene.
End on a quiet moment
Some writers end a scene on a thought instead of a laugh, once the audience trusts them.
How to decide. In a cold open of three to five lines, end on the laugh. A look or a silence can carry it, but an ending with no laugh in it scores low on this rubric.
On the ladder · The last line
- 1The scene ends on setup, runs past its best moment, or ends on its weakest moment.
- 2It ends on a joke, then an explanation, a tag or a reaction weakens it.
- 3It stops on its strongest moment, but the ending is the one the setup promised, or the laugh is in the middle of the last line.
- 4The ending is a surprise and the laugh lands at the very end, but the surprise comes from outside the scene.
- 5The ending pays off something the scene put in place without pointing at it, and it does not explain itself.
Idea 1 takes you from rung 2 to rung 3. Idea 2 and an ending the setup did not promise get you to rung 4. Idea 3, a quiet plant, is the step from 4 to 5. The full text of every rung is on How you're scored.
Cheat sheet
- Stop on the laugh.No reaction line, no explanation, no extra step of plot.
- Put the laugh word last.Keep the meaning. Change the order of the words.
- The button can be an action or a silence.Whatever it is, nothing comes after it.
- Write five endings and keep the best surprise.The surprise must still come from the scene.
- Pay off something the scene already planted.A quiet plant scores above a surprise from outside, and both above a promised ending.
- Keep the character's voice.If the button sounds like a writer, rewrite it or give it to someone else.
What this chapter doesn't claim
These rules fix the most common problem in short comic scenes: an ending that keeps talking. They are not laws of comedy. Longer scenes sometimes end on a quiet moment on purpose, and some comics hold back a punch line. In a cold open of three to five lines, end on the laugh.
Write it
In this rep, four neighbors are on a landing on a Saturday morning. Simone has promised her plus-one (the extra guest on a wedding invitation) to two different people, and both of them are standing there.
The trap. In this rep, the funniest line often arrives before the end, and then you keep writing to solve the problem. You don't have to solve anything. Before you write a new line, look at what is already in the scene. Find the laugh, put its word last, and stop.
The Second Invitation